
INEC asks court to set aside subpoena for Tinubu's 1999 and 2023 forms in Sowore trial: its reasons and what the court decides next
The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) has asked the Federal High Court in Abuja to set aside a subpoena directing its chairman, Professor Joash Amupitan, to produce President Bola Tinubu's nomination forms for the 1999 Lagos governorship election and the 2023 presidential election. The documents were requested by the defence in the criminal trial of activist Omoyele Sowore. INEC says the chairman was not personally served, that the forms as described do not exist in its custody, and that the request was made in bad faith. The court had not ruled on the application before Wednesday's hearing.
The motion was filed on Tuesday 10 November through INEC's lawyer, Alex Izinyon (SAN), and was received at the court registry at 3.45pm, Premium Times reported. It came a day before Amupitan was due to appear on Wednesday 11 November as a subpoenaed defence witness in the case, FHC/CR/484/2025, before Justice Mohammed Garba Umar. Sowore is being prosecuted by the Department of State Services (DSS) over social media posts in which he allegedly called President Tinubu a 'criminal'.
INEC gave four grounds. It described the subpoena, issued on 26 October, as 'void ab initio, ungrantable, inconsistent and contradictory'. It said Amupitan was not personally served, as the law requires; according to a supporting affidavit, the document was delivered to the commission's Litigation and Prosecution Department in Abuja at about 12.30pm on 6 November. It said there is no form known as INEC CF01 for either election and that the forms as described are not in the chairman's custody. It also accused the defence of acting in bad faith, calling the request irrelevant, speculative and intended to embarrass the commission, Premium Times, Independent and Sahara Reporters reported. The affidavit added that Amupitan is not a party to the case and is not the maker of the documents.
The subpoena, dated 26 October and sought by Sowore's lawyer, Reuben Adakole, was reported on Monday 9 November alongside rulings in which the court cleared APC chieftain Joe Igbokwe to be called as a defence witness and set aside a separate subpoena on the DSS lead counsel. Independent noted that INEC's application does not establish whether the underlying records exist in another form; that question is separate from its objections to how the subpoena was framed and served. ST Office did not find a response from the Presidency or the APC at the time of writing.
Pidgin: INEC don go court make dem cancel di subpoena wey order im chairman Joash Amupitan to bring President Tinubu nomination forms for 1999 Lagos governorship and 2023 presidential election for Sowore case. INEC talk say dem no serve di chairman by imself, say di forms as dem describe am no dey for im custody, and say di request na bad faith. Court never decide yet. Di case dey continue Wednesday 11 November.
How this affects you: Nothing has been decided about the documents themselves. The court will first hear INEC's application and any reply from Sowore's lawyers, then rule on whether the subpoena stands, is amended or is set aside. Watch for that ruling and for whether INEC is ordered to produce certified copies in another form. For voters, the wider point is that candidates' nomination papers are filed with INEC before every election, and the Freedom of Information Act lets members of the public apply for records held by public bodies. If you share news about this case, rely on reports of what was filed and said in court rather than edited clips or claims about what the documents contain.
Share on WhatsAppJoin the debate
No comments yet. Be the first.
